Understanding Capacity and Competence
As your parents grow older, you may start to notice changes in their behavior or decision-making abilities. Perhaps your 87-year-old father’s house has become increasingly unkempt, yet he refuses to accept help. Or maybe your aging aunt is giving large sums of money to strangers who call her on the phone. These concerning situations can prompt worries about your loved one’s mental capacity and competence.
It’s a sensitive and often complex issue, but understanding the differences between capacity and competence, as well as the clinical and legal processes involved, can help guide you in supporting your aging parent.
Clinical Capacity vs. Legal Competence
Capacity and competence are related but distinct concepts. Clinical capacity refers to an individual’s ability to make specific decisions, such as managing their finances, consenting to medical treatment, or living independently. This is typically assessed by healthcare professionals, like doctors or psychologists, who evaluate the person’s cognitive functioning and decision-making abilities.
Legal competence, on the other hand, is a legal determination made by the courts. It involves assessing whether an individual has the mental capacity to make their own decisions and manage their own affairs. This can result in a legal finding of “incompetence,” which may lead to the appointment of a guardian or conservator to make decisions on the person’s behalf.
Capacity is Decision-Specific and Fluctuates
It’s important to understand that capacity is not an all-or-nothing proposition. A person may have the capacity to make some decisions but lack the capacity for others, depending on the complexity of the decision and the individual’s cognitive abilities. Additionally, a person’s capacity can fluctuate over time, particularly for those living with dementia or other cognitive impairments.
For example, an older adult may have the capacity to manage their daily routine and personal care but lack the capacity to make complex financial decisions. Or they may have good decision-making abilities when they are feeling well but experience significant difficulties when they are ill or under stress.
Recognizing Potential Capacity Issues
So, how can you tell if your aging parent may be experiencing capacity issues? Here are some signs to watch for:
Changes in Behavior or Decision-Making
Pay attention to any significant changes in your parent’s behavior, decision-making, or ability to manage their daily activities. This could include:
- Increased difficulty with tasks that require organization, problem-solving, or memory, such as paying bills, managing medications, or keeping the home clean and safe.
- Making uncharacteristic or questionable decisions, like giving large sums of money to strangers or refusing to address safety concerns.
- Neglecting their personal care, such as poor hygiene or weight loss due to inadequate nutrition.
Cognitive Decline or Dementia
Cognitive impairments, such as those associated with Alzheimer’s disease or other forms of dementia, can significantly affect a person’s decision-making capacity. Signs of cognitive decline may include:
- Frequently getting lost or disoriented, even in familiar surroundings
- Difficulty following conversations or remembering recent events
- Struggling to complete once-routine tasks or make decisions
- Changes in mood, personality, or behavior
Physical or Mental Health Issues
Certain physical or mental health conditions can also impact an individual’s capacity, at least temporarily. These may include:
- Delirium, which can be caused by infections, medication side effects, or other acute medical problems
- Depression or anxiety, which can affect a person’s ability to make sound decisions
- Chronic pain or mobility issues that make it difficult to manage daily tasks
Navigating the Capacity Assessment Process
If you’re concerned about your parent’s capacity, the first step is to seek a professional evaluation. This typically involves the following steps:
-
Clinical Assessment: A healthcare provider, such as a geriatric physician, geriatric psychiatrist, or neuropsychologist, will conduct a comprehensive evaluation to assess your parent’s cognitive, functional, and decision-making abilities.
-
Capacity Determination: Based on the assessment, the clinician will provide an opinion on your parent’s capacity to make specific decisions, such as managing finances, consenting to medical treatment, or living independently.
-
Legal Determination: If the clinical assessment suggests significant capacity issues, you may need to pursue a legal determination of incompetence through the court system. This may involve additional evaluations and the potential appointment of a guardian or conservator.
It’s important to note that the legal process can be complex and may vary depending on your state’s laws. Consulting with an elder law attorney can help you navigate the specific requirements and procedures in your area.
Overcoming Resistance and Improving Outcomes
Your aging parent may be resistant to the idea of a capacity assessment or accepting assistance, fearing a loss of independence or control. Here are some strategies to help overcome this resistance and improve outcomes:
Communicate with Empathy and Respect
Approach the conversation with empathy, understanding, and a focus on maintaining your parent’s dignity. Avoid confrontational or accusatory language, and instead emphasize your concerns for their well-being and your desire to support their goals of independence and quality of life.
Involve Your Parent in Decision-Making
Whenever possible, include your parent in the decision-making process. Solicit their input, acknowledge their preferences, and work collaboratively to find solutions that address their needs while respecting their autonomy.
Enlist Professional and Community Support
Seek the assistance of your parent’s healthcare providers, social workers, or community resources to help persuade your parent to accept the necessary evaluations or support services. Having an objective third party involved can sometimes make a significant difference.
Prioritize Your Parent’s Safety and Well-Being
In situations where your parent’s safety or well-being is at immediate risk, you may need to take more assertive action, even if it means overriding their wishes. This could involve contacting adult protective services or pursuing legal guardianship. While this should be a last resort, it’s important to prioritize your parent’s well-being.
Caring for Yourself and Your Family
Navigating the challenges of an aging parent’s capacity issues can be emotionally and physically draining. Remember to prioritize your own self-care and seek support from others. Consider the following:
- Enlist the help of other family members or trusted friends to share the caregiving burden.
- Connect with support groups or counseling services to process your feelings and find strategies for coping.
- Take regular breaks and practice stress-management techniques, such as mindfulness or exercise.
Ultimately, the goal is to support your aging parent while respecting their autonomy and maintaining their dignity. By understanding the capacity assessment process, communicating effectively, and seeking professional and community assistance, you can help ensure the best possible outcomes for your loved one.
